What does Erie Insurance's Subscriber Agreement mean?

The reciprocal insurance agreement can be quite confusing. However, its function is quite simple.

When we place business for our clients in the Erie Insurance Exchange, the client will need to sign an agreement that looks like this:

Screen Shot 2021-02-18 at 11.04.36 AM

It is a bit confusing and clients often have questions about exactly what this is that they are signing.  It all has to do with Erie's corporate structure as a reciprocal insurer.

What is a reciprocal insurer?

It is a kind of insurance organization whereby insured's agree to spread their risk among one another.  This is pretty much the goal of all forms of insurance.  It requires 2 entities, an "Attorney-in-fact" and a "Reciprocal Exchange".

With Erie's structure, policyholders are referred to as "Subscribers".  The "Subscriber's Agreement" is what allows them to place coverage for clients and transact business for them.

What are you signing?

*This is a generalization.  We are not attorneys and do not give legal advice.  

Items 1 through 7 lay out exactly what you and the company agree to, including:

  • You agree to pay premiums and have those premiums used to pay your claims as well as those other subscribers that may have claims.
  • Erie is allowed to transact standard business such as obtaining and canceling policies, collect premiums, obtain reinsurance, settle claims, invest reserves, etc.
  • Erie Insurance Exchange may only keep up to 25% of all premiums for their services.  This includes all overhead and other expenses.  This is key and will be addressed further below.
  • The agreement applies to all of your Erie policies
  • You will comply with any paperwork required to make the agreement work.
  • The agreement does not change should you become disabled or incapacitated.
  • This applies to you and others such as executors should you pass.

Item #3. in the agreement is especially important and is also a key reason why Erie's reciprocal approach makes sense and tends to keep rates low.  It says that Erie can only take up to 25 cents of every dollar collected by the Exchange for overhead, admin, commission, and other expenses.  That means the other 75 cents MUST go toward paying claims.

This is an especially low expense ratio and gives Erie a competitive advantage over other companies that are not restricted similarly and can dip further into collected premiums for such expenses.  This has resulted in Erie having plenty of money in reserve to pay claims and renders them less vulnerable to extreme pricing swings when large claims events occur.

Are you giving them Power-of-Attorney as you see with families?

No.  The rights that you are giving them are limited only to transacting insurance business within the exchange.  Nothing more.  Nothing less.

The limited powers are spelled out in item #2.  It also makes clear that "The power of attorney is limited to the purposes described in this agreement".